|
Significance
Stroke is the third leading cause of death and
the leading cause of adult disability in the United States. Each
year in the US, over 750,000 Americans suffer a symptomatic
stroke. More than 4 out of 5 strokes are due to ischemic
infarction. Unfortunately, current therapies for acute ischemic
stroke are of extremely limited effectiveness. To date, the only
FDA approved treatment for acute ischemic stroke is intravenous
tissue plasminogen activator (tPA), a thrombolytic agent which
must be administered within 3 hours of symptom onset, and only
after neuroimaging has ruled out intracerebral hemorrhage.
Current estimates are that only 1-3% of acute ischemic stroke
patients in the US receive TPA. The only other agent of proven
utility in acute ischemic stroke is aspirin, which confers only
minimal benefit, helping only one of every 110 patients treated.
New, effective, widely applicable treatments for acute ischemic
stroke are desperately needed.
The FAST-MAG Study
will address this urgent need in two critical ways: 1) the study
will constitute a definitive phase 3 trial of magnesium sulfate,
a highly promising neuroprotective agent; and 2) the study will
pioneer the prehospital initiation of neuroprotective agents in
pivotal clinical trials of neuroprotective agents, permitting
more patients to be treated in the first critical minutes after
onset, and solving a major design defect of prior trials of
neuroprotective stroke therapy.
The Neuroprotective Strategy for Treatment of Acute Stroke
When focal occlusions
disrupt blood flow to the brain, a cascade of molecular events
producing cell injury ensues. Cell death proceeds rapidly in the
infarct core, where blood flow is most drastically curtailed,
but more slowly in the ischemic penumbra, where blood flow is
variably reduced and molecular elaboration of neuronal injury
may proceed over hours. Central molecular events in the ischemic
cascade include accumulation of intracellular calcium, release
of excitatory amino acid neurotransmitters, generation of
oxygen-free radicals, nitric oxide formation, and the release of
cytokines by infiltrating polymorphonuclear leukocytes. These
and additional events afford numerous targets for pharmacologic
blockade. A multitude of neuroprotective drugs interfering with
various pathways of ischemic injury reduce infarct volume
substantially in focal stroke animal models when administered
10-120 minutes after ischemia onset, including excitatory amino
acid antagonists, oxygen free radical scavengers, and voltage
sensitive calcium channel blockers.
The ideal
neuroprotective agent for stroke would be inexpensive, readily
available, easy to administer and have no significant adverse
side effects. An agent demonstrated to be safe and potentially
beneficial in both ischemic and hemorrhagic stroke would have
the added benefit of potentially earlier administration prior to
obtaining a head CT scan. Intravenous magnesium sulfate offers
promise as just such an agent.
Magnesium Sulfate
Magnesium ions cross
the intact blood-brain barrier efficaciously so that intravenous
magnesium sulfate significantly raises cerebrospinal fluid and
brain extracellular fluid magnesium to supraphysiologic
levels.[5,6] Magnesium sulfate is neuroprotective in preclinical
models of cerebral and spinal cord ischemia, excitotoxic injury,
and head trauma. Magnesium (Mg) is economical, widely available,
simple to administer and has a long established safety and
tolerability profile in myocardial infarction and eclampsia, as
well as in pilot human focal stroke studies. Unlike most
synthetic neuroprotective compounds, parenteral magnesium has no
major adverse effects in doses that achieve serum levels in the
range of preclinical neuroprotective concentrations.
Laboratory studies
have identified multiple neuronal and vascular effects of
magnesium that likely contribute to the potent neuroprotective
effects observed in stroke models, as delineated in a recent
comprehensive review. In a wide variety of in vitro systems and
animal models, magnesium has been shown to inhibit presynaptic
release of excitatory neurotransmitters, noncompetitively block
the N-methyl-D-aspartate (NMDA) receptor, presynaptically
potentiate adenosine, block voltage-gated calcium channels,
suppress cortical spreading depression and anoxic
depolarizations, relax vascular smooth muscle resulting in
vasodilation of large and small vascular beds and increased
cerebral blood flow, antagonize endothelin-1 and other
vasoconstrictors, and replete an underlying and/or
ischemia-induced Mg deficient state.
Magnesium is
neuroprotective in rodent models of reversible and permanent
focal cerebral ischemia and in animal models of global ischemia.
At least nine preclinical studies have examined the effect of
systemic magnesium sulfate upon final infarct size in animal
focal ischemic stroke models. Eight of the nine demonstrated
substantial decreases in infarct size in treated animals, with
reductions ranging from 26-61% in unconfounded studies.
Eight phase 2 trials
of magnesium in focal human stroke have been performed. All
suggested good tolerability and potential efficacy.
An international phase
III trial of late, in-hospital administration of magnesium in
focal human stroke was reported in 2004, the Intravenous
Magnesium Efficacy in Stroke Trial (IMAGES) study, funded by the
British Medical Research Council. The IMAGES trial was designed
at a time when the crucial need to treat patients within the
first few hours after stroke onset was not fully appreciated.
Accordingly, the IMAGES trial permitted enrollment of stroke
patients up until 12 hours after stroke onset. Final worldwide
enrollment was 2589 patients.
Overall, IMAGES was a
neutral trial, with no statistically significant effect of
magnesium sulfate on the primary endpoint of reduced death or
disability, nor on any secondary efficacy or safety endpoint.
Most relevant to FAST-MAG are the results observed in IMAGES for
patients enrolled in early time epochs. Among the 79 patients
enrolled within 3 hours of onset, on the IMAGES primary
endpoint, the global odds ratio comparing magnesium vs placebo
for a favorable death or disability outcome was 0.66 (95%CI
0.25-1.70). Considering the modified Rankin component of the
IMAGES primary endpoint, a non-disabled outcome (mRS 0-1) was
achieved in 45.9% of magnesium patients vs 33.3% of placebo
patients, a 12.6% absolute difference. The IMAGES data thus
provide a signal of potential efficacy of magnesium sulfate in
acute stroke when administered within the first 3 hours after
stroke onset. FAST-MAG will constitute a definitive, phase 3
trial test to validate this signal of potential benefit.
Prior Neuroprotective Agent Trials, the Key Variable of Time,
and the Prehospital Strategy
In the past several
decades, more than 50 neuroprotective agents have been tested in
randomized controlled clinical trials in acute ischemic stroke,
but none has been shown unequivocally to be beneficial in
definitive phase III trials. Leading basic and clinial
neuroscientists have identified 4 key design defects of past
human clinical trials of neuroprotective clinical trials: 1)
failure to administer study agents at neuroprotective doses in
humans because of limiting side effects, 2) failure to select
patients for trials who will respond to the known mechanisms of
action of study drug, 3) failure to employ sample sizes large
enough to detect modest benefits of study agent, and 4) failure
to treat patients early enough after stroke onset.
The FAST-MAG trial is
designed to remedy each of these past difficulties. The trial
will employ magnesium sulfate at doses known to be both well
tolerated and to yield serum levels neuroprotective in animal
models. The trial will employ an agent likely to be beneficial
for both gray and white matter ischemic injury, based on
vasodilating effects in both superficial and deep circulations
and cytoprotective effects in both gray and white matter. The
trial is adequately powered to detect even a modest treatment
effect, and will be larger than 95% of all previous phase 3
neuroprotective trials.
Most importantly, the
FAST-MAG trial is designed to address the crucial factor of
delayed time to treatment which has hindered all past human
clinical trials of neuroprotective drugs. Rodent and nonhuman
primate experimental studies suggest the duration of the
therapeutic window within which neuroprotective intervention can
ameliorate bioenergetic failure in the ischemic penumbra is very
brief, generally less than 2-3 hours. Most animal studies of
neuroprotective agents initiate therapy within 1-60 minutes
after ischemia onset. However, although it is in the first 2
hours of onset that neuroprotective agents in general are
beneficial in focal animal stroke models, no prior human
clinical neuroprotective agent trial has enrolled any
substantial cohort of patients in this time window. Devising
methods to safely initiate experimental neuroprotective
therapies more quickly is critical if the dramatic benefits of
neuroprotective agents evident in the laboratory are to be
achieved in human stroke victims.
Enrolling patients in
the field in acute neuroprotective trials is a highly promising
approach to the challenge of testing neuroprotective agents in
hyperacute time epochs. Panels of emergency physicians and
neurologists active in stroke research have suggested the
desirability of paramedic treatment of acute stroke in the
field. A vision of future stroke care widely shared in the
stroke research community is: 1) paramedic administration of a
group of complementary neuroprotective agents in the field to
protect the brain during transfer and extend the time window for
recanalization therapy, 2) definitive thrombolysis or other
revascularization procedure on hospital arrival, and 3)
in-hospital administration of a second group of neuroprotective
agents specifically active against reperfusion injury.
Feasibility of Prehospital Neuroprotection in Focal Stroke -
The FAST-MAG Pilot Trial
Prehospital trials for
focal stroke pose several unique study design challenges,
including stroke identification, stroke characterization,
deficit evolution in the field, and consent elicitation. To
address these issues, a pilot trial was performed and
demonstrated the practicality for a pivotal trial of several
prehospital trial instruments, including the Los Angeles
Prehospital Stroke Screen (LAPSS) to identify patients for trial
entry, the Los Angeles Motor Scale (LAMS) for pretreatment
characterization of stroke severity, the Paramedic Global
Impression of Change score to delineate prehospital deficit
evolution, and physician cell phone elicitation of consent for
trial participation in the field (Saver JL, Kidwell C, Eckstein
M, Starkman S, for the FAST-MAG Pilot Trial Investigators.
Prehospital neuroprotective therapy for acute stroke: results of
the Field Administration of Stroke Therapy – Magnesium
(FAST-MAG) Pilot Trial. Stroke 2004;35:e106-e108. (DOI:
10.1161/01.STR.0000124458.98123.52). Prehospital enrollment in
the FAST-MAG Pilot Trial succeeded in accelerating start of
neuroprotective therapy, decreasing the interval from paramedic
arrival on scene to start of study infusion by nearly 2 hours.
Clinical outcomes in the open-label pilot trial must be
interpreted cautiously, but were encouraging. Dramatic early
recovery occurred in 42% of <2h infarct patients. Good 90 day
global functional outcome (Rankin < 2) was achieved by 69% of
all patients and 75% of <2h infarct patients. No serious adverse
events specifically related to field initiation of study agent
were noted.
The FAST-MAG Pilot
Trial demonstrated that field initiation of magnesium sulfate in
acute stroke is feasible, safe, and potentially efficacious.
Based on these results, the large-scale, pivotal FAST-MAG Phase
3 trial of magnesium sulfate was planned with field initiation
of study agent within 1-2h of onset, a time window not
previously explored in neuroprotective studies, when the
benefits of neuroprotective acute stroke therapies are likely to
be greatest. By utilizing field delivery, the FAST-MAG trial
will be the first neuroprotective study ever performed in the
0-2 hour window, when patients are most likely to benefit from
neuroprotective interventions
Back to top |